I say what I say knowing full well that I may be attacked for my first ever formalized and publicly expressed television show review. But, knowing that as well as the fact that there are already many voices in LOST fandom, I felt compelled to say something of last week’s episode, ‘Everybody Loves Hugo’, which centers on Hurley, or Hugo Reyes (as is obvious from its title). As this is experimental, I kind of just chose five things that are important to me and went from there.
VALUE
Okay, first off, this episode was very entertaining and we did get some answers. The whispers are dead people stuck on the island? Not sure how this works with Ben’s comment to Rousseau last season (“When you hear whispers, run the other way!” – not verbatim), but it’s nice to know the facts all the same. This particular fact also ups the re-watch value of many previous episodes in which dead people have appeared and in which whispers were heard. And, for me personally, seeing Desmond work some magic brought joy to my soul. Not to mention the fact that, overall, this episode was about a man doing his best to do what’s right.
STORY
Who doesn’t like a real advancement of the plot? Having the episode end with both Jack seeing Locke on the island for the first time (as his new self, of course) and Desmond pulling a hit-and-run on Locke off-island made for a gripping and unsettling ending: just the thing I like about LOST. For the first time this season, too, we got to see Hurley–the heart of the show and the most likely person to make good decisions–in action as a leader. While Desmond getting tossed down the well was predictable from the beginning of the scene, the story of this episode overall seemed to be the watershed we needed after some answers came to us in Desmond’s ‘Happily Ever After’.
WRITING
However, I had a real problem with the writing. Eddy Kitsis and Adam Horowitz did a fantastic job with ‘Dr. Linus’ many weeks ago, but this one had a lot of dead conversation and some strange, unLOST-like moments. Like, why did Hurley have to walk off into the bushes and have this blatantly revelatory little exchange with Michael of “Oh, these are the what the whispers are”? And it might have been better if the scenes with Libby weren’t so…awkward. Yeah, she might be a ‘loony,’ but I don’t think she was given very good lines. “Do you believe that two people can be soul mates?” and “Then I’m not crazy!” needed a bit more exposition or should have been expressed a different way. The order of events throughout the episode was great, but the dialogue needed some work.
CHARACTERS
That said, the character development was pretty good. Desmond continues the fulfillment of his self-proclaimed purpose, Hurley steps up to the plate, and Jack connects with Hurley’s leadership in an important way. On the down side, I was disappointed in the randomly strange decision of Richard, Ben, and Miles to part ways with the rest of the group. As many have already pointed out, they left the candidates!! I don’t know about you, but that seems like a poor decision to me. Even then, I respect that different characters react different ways. The one that made the least sense to me was Ben’s very fast choice of Richard over Hurley. I know Ben’s been with Richard almost his entire life, but Ben said himself that Richard doesn’t know anything. And, as everybody can see, Richard has changed recently and he’s more likely to say things like “We’re all dead!!” He doesn’t seem like that great of a leader.
ACTING
I think it’s mostly due to the writing, but I was not impressed with Jorge Garcia’s acting in the beach scene when he realized the alternate timeline. It seemed like this should have been a more pivotal moment for him, but he kind of had this weird eyebrow furrowing thing that didn’t speak ‘surprise’ or ‘amazement.’ More so, it said ‘curious,’ which seemed out of place. On the flip side, I thoroughly enjoyed Harold Perrineau’s reprise of Michael. He did a superb job with what few lines he had, especially in his apology to Libby via Hurley in the on-island sequence.
OVERALL
Well, I love LOST, so I really shouldn’t complain. Compared with other Season 6 episodes, though, this one didn’t measure up. It had some great story development, but the writing and acting mainly bothered me. But would I watch it again? Yes!
11/15, B










